health

ENVIRONMENT: Critics Weigh In as IFC Tightens Mining Rules

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Sep 10 2007 (IPS) – The International Finance Corporation (IFC) faces pointed criticism in coming days as an effort to lessen the damage wrought by large mining projects enters a new phase.
Mining pollution in the Philippines Credit: IUCN/CEESP

Mining pollution in the Philippines Credit: IUCN/CEESP

At issue are updates and enhancements to environmental, health, and social guidelines from the World Bank s private sector arm. Green groups and international charities say the proposed changes lack adequate standards in critical areas such as water contamination and the disposal of toxic waste.

They further question the economic benefits of mining in poor countries.

The groups, in a 20-page critique, decry a failure to stipulate appropriate protections to prevent contamination of local water sources by toxic chemicals, ensure proper disposal of mine waste or guarantee prior community consultation on the design of mine closure plans.

Critics include the World Wildlife Fund, Oxfam, Earthworks, Bank Information Centre, and Centre for Science in Public Participation. The groups complaints come as the IFC draws up specific standards for mining and more than 60 other industries as part of a broader effort to apply, at project sites, global performance standards updated last year.

In coming days, the activists views will be balanced against feedback from other non-governmental organisations (NGOs), mining companies, and governments, said an IFC spokesman. The agency on Friday closed a 60-day period of public comment on the nascent rules.
Related IPS Articles

These NGOs have given their input into that process and this is welcome as it is what we wanted and asked for, the spokesman, Hannfried von Hindenburg, told IPS.

This input we will take into account and it will have an influence, in one way or another, although I cannot say now how much of it we will take on, he added.

The NGO report advances specific language its authors say must be used if the IFC guidelines are to pass muster. Proposed amendments cover issues such as water conservation and quality, acid drainage, groundwater protection, reclamation of waste rock dumps and the management of worthless ore, known as tailings.

These and other areas of concern are covered by the draft IFC guidelines, some for the first time and some in greater detail than before. Even so, the activist coalition says in its critique that the emerging document lacks specific targets the IFC can use to decide whether to back a given project or to judge its performance.

The draft IFC mining guidelines, like their predecessors, do not contain sufficient quantitative standards and requirements for IFC project approval. This means that during application almost everything is left to the judgement and discretion of the IFC reviewer of the project, says the NGO critique. Ultimately, this level of discretion is not protective of communities, countries, or companies.

The guidelines are designed mainly to apply to new IFC-financed projects. As with earlier versions, and because they lay out international best practice, the rules also are destined to serve as benchmarks against which mining companies will set goals or be judged by critics regardless of IFC involvement.

As such, the guidelines will enjoy authority far greater than the IFC s small financial presence in mining worldwide. That is why, over the years, interested parties ranging from environmentalists and aid groups to local communities, governments, and corporations have sought to influence the rules. The IFC has had to strike difficult compromises between those groups often competing demands.

Mining s critics long have said the extraction of natural wealth constitutes a so-called resource curse in poor countries, where it contributes neither to economic growth nor to poverty reduction yet sparks or fuels health and environmental crises and armed conflict. Nigeria often is cited as the prime example.

Opponents of that view point to Botswana, Chile and, going further back in history, to Australia, Canada, and the United States as countries where mining played a key role in diversifying and developing national economies.

The IFC s critics, in their document, urge the agency to detail the positive and negative impacts of each of its mining investments on a project-specific basis.

This, they say, will enable the IFC to report meaningfully on whether its mining investments actually reduce poverty.

The World Bank Group, of which the IFC is a member, itself concluded in 2004 that it needed to enhance its efforts in more explicitly identifying and tracking poverty reduction associated with its projects.

The agencies long have acknowledged what some term a paradox of plenty : In some countries, extractive industries have failed to generate sustainable benefits for society despite providing jobs and producing revenue.

The IFC s environmental, health, and social safeguards are aimed at addressing these very problems, officials have said.

 

Related Posts

Get a job- Google is looking to hire a Graphics Engineer

The Gamasutra Job Board is the most diverse, active and established board of its kind for the video game industry!

Here is just one of the many, many positions being advertised right now.

Graphics EngineerGoogle

Location: Mountain View, CA

Google is not a conventional company, and we don’t intend to become one. True, we share attributes with the world’s most successful organizations – a focus on innovation and smart business practices comes to mind – but even as we continue to…

Get a job- Heart Machine is hiring a Gameplay Engineer

The Gamasutra Job Board is the most diverse, active and established board of its kind for the video game industry!

Here is just one of the many, many positions being advertised right now.

Gameplay Engineer, Heart Machine

Location: Culver City, California Come from South African Online Casinos

Heart Machine is a small, deeply motivated and close-knit team located in Los Angeles. Our focus is gameplay that’s engaging, fluid an…

Get a job- Hi-Rez Studios seeks a Character Rigger

The Gamasutra Job Board is the most diverse, active and established board of its kind for the video game industry!

Here is just one of the many, many positions being advertised right now.

Character RiggerHi-Rez Studios

Location: Alpharetta, GA

Hi-Rez Studios is immediately hiring a qualified character rigger to work at our studio in Alpharetta, Georgia.

Come join the creator of the critically acclaimed Smite,

Experimental Gameplay Workshop returns to GDC 2014 with star lineup

With less than two weeks remaining before the Game Developers Conference 2014, show organizers are detailing the lineup of the ever-popular Experimental Gameplay Workshop, which returns to GDC for its 12th year. This jam-packed two-hour session — which takes place Friday, March 21 at 2:30pm in Room 135 of the San Francisco Moscone Center's North Hall — will showcase an eclectic mix of unusual game prototypes that defy convention and explore new ideas and genres. This year the EGW is curated and organized by leading creators Robin Hunicke and Daniel Benmergui, and it promises to be an exciting opportunity for presenters and attendees alike to explore some fresh territory in game design. A number of 'experimental' …

Black Ops 6 Reveal Trailer Provides First Glimpse At 2024's Call Of Duty

The first trailer for Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 is out now. The trailer doesn’t show any footage, but is instead a live-action mood piece that features a number of real-world political leaders, including Bill Clinton, George H.W. Bush, Margaret Thatcher, and Saddam Hussein.

The trailer’s thumbnail also contains coordinates that point to the location of Hussein’s palace. The game seems be themed around questioning the government’s version of facts. “If it’s the truth you seek, look in the dark,” reads a line from the trailer’s description. Take a look at the trailer below.

Balatro Hits Big Sales Milestone After Being Showered With Awards

Developer Localthunk has revealed that Balatro has recently passed the 5 million sales milestone across all platforms. Come from South African Online Casinos

“The last few weeks have been pretty wild. To everyone who picked up Balatro after seeing it at The Game Awards, we hope you’re having an amazing time with it,” the developer said on Twitter. “If this is your first time picking up an indie title, try to make it a habit!”

According to Balatro’s publisher, Playstack, the 5 million mark doesn’t include downloads from Apple Arcade. Additionally, the game was sitting at 3.5 million copies sold at the first week of December, indicating that it received a boost in exposure after being nominated as a Game of t…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *